top of page

"John used his knowledge of the local market to assist us with pricing & negotiations in selling two 2-family income properties, and navigate the purchase of a single-family condo which could be rented. John was helpful in locating condos, and was efficient and patient in setting up showings. He is a great Buyers Agent, keeping our sales and purchases straight forward. We decided to also have John find us the right tenant for the new property. John took care of all the details. Thank you, John!" - BJ G.

"John was an excellent realtor for us as we managed the market to buy and sell a property at the same time! He was very patient, knowledgeable, and honest through the whole process. In this extremely competitive market, it was reassuring to know that he was our safety net and made sure we made decisions we would be comfortable with going forward. We never felt pressured and always felt comforted by his input. He was an active listener and got to know us as buyers and sellers -- he knew exactly what we wanted and helped us secure it! His honesty went so far to tell us when he would avoid a home vs which homes would be hot offers. He was not afraid to reach out to the buying/selling agents. He made the process as quick and painless as could be. Would 12/10 recommend John to anyone looking for a realtor! We hope to use his services again! Thanks John!" - Shree P. & Michelle T.

"John was amazing! His knowledge, charm, energy, and honesty were exactly what we needed. He used his vast knowledge and experience to help secure the home of our dreams. He was always there when we needed him. I have recommended him to anyone that is even considering a move. In short, he was a godsend." -Mike B. & Deidra F. 

“’Doesn't matter if it's 1 home or 1000, I'll find you the right home.’ Many agents say something to this effect but none truly live it. John will stick by you every step of the way. Any property we buy or sell in the future will be a Molitor property!" - Eric W.

"John Molitor was amazing. He is extremely knowledgeable and we felt so comfortable working with him. He never pushed us and knew when we found our new house that would be the right one. He points out good and bad in every house and is so honest. Always there when you need him. John Molitor is an absolute gem and I would refer him to any one I know who is selling and buying a new home. You know you are in perfect hands. Honest and a real Mench!" - Nancy M.

"John was an absolute pleasure to work with. My wife and I just recently moved to Wisconsin and was very unfamiliar with the area. John's knowledge of south eastern Wisconsin is second to none. He showed us houses in several different areas and could speak about the positive and negatives of each area. Ultimately we fell in love with Whitefish Bay. John was able to find us a great home in a highly competitive market and was instrumental in getting our bid accepted. John was very professional, very responsive to questions, and was very accommodating to our schedules. More than that John is a kind, funny, and all around great person. We will certainly recommend John to all of our friends and family." - Chris D. & Sarah V.

"John assisted us with the purchase of our vacation property. He was extremely responsive and helped us understand each step in the process. And where there was new paperwork to review/approve, he'd help us understand the legalese and give his opinion based on his extensive experience. Highly recommend." - Mark & Laura H.

"John and his team are incredible. They were very helpful, knowledgeable and responsive. We met him through rental searches, and after doing some more due diligence realize it would be easier for us to buy in Milwaukee. He really gave us a great outline of the real estate landscape and very helpful to try to find what would be best for us. We were looking to take our time with finding a place, but John and his team are great at showing us properties that would be a great fit for us and we ended up finding something a lot sooner than we had expected. We are very happy to be new to Milwaukee and would highly recommend John to anyone looking to move to the Milwaukee area." - Amit P. & Namrata P.

"An all around great guy. An absolute JOY to work with in the entire home buying process. Amen. John is very helpful, understanding and diligent as well as being very knowledgeable about the Greater Milwaukee real estate environment. His enthusiasm is a blessing and his knowledge of all the paperwork, construction inspection(s), mortgage involvement, etc., truly made purchasing a home a happy experience. My wife and I could not have asked for any better person, because John is truly a caring, kind, understanding, and knowledgeable realtor. I know anyone considering a home purchase will be more than assured and very pleased/satisfied in having John Molitor as your realtor. We most certainly highly recommend him." - Aldred & Nicole M. 

We are so grateful to have been able to work with John in both selling our home and finding our new one. John is understanding, patient, resourceful, and was all-around a pleasure to work with. We would highly recommend him for any buying and selling needs. He never missed a beat, was available at any time we had questions, concerns or needed follow-up, and was just as excited as we were while going through this process." - Rachel M. & Michael P.

"We call him the Magic Man. Moving from a home to a condo, we had very specific needs , as well as issues of finding a condo that we would pay for with the cash from our home sale. (to avoid withdrawing funds from retirement). The timing was critical. No matter what anyone says, this is not an easy move. But not for John. John never flinched once. He was available whenever we called and answered any questions. He also has an efficient and friendly team that exudes confidence and is available to us as well. He is a wealth of knowledge of the industry, is personable, efficient and he's "real". There are no obstacles to buying and selling that he can't handle. In a matter of 5 days our Offer to Purchase was accepted and our home was sold. Now that was magic!" - Beverly & Patrick P.

"John has been a real pleasure to work with! Having grown up in the area John is super knowledgeable about the different pockets in the local neighborhoods, knows the history of many of the houses and has a great eye for both design and technical features of a house. He also kept an even keel and a calculated voice in this hot market through tough negotiation processes.  I highly recommend partnering with John." - Tom R.

"John was extremely responsive right off the bat during the search for my first duplex. He answered my many questions with enthusiasm in a timely fashion. He also utilized his vast local network to introduce me to off-market opportunities. With the help of John, the entire home buying process was smooth and efficient. It's clear John loves what he does, and he does it well!" - Blake R.

"Buying a house can be a scary and difficult process even in the best of markets. Finding someone who is patient and understands what you want makes all the difference in the world. We found that combination with John. During the whole process he was communicative, thoughtful, and optimistic. I honestly don't believe we would have been able to buy our house without John, he is without a doubt the best around." - Rob & Katie B.

"John helped our daughter with her home purchase and she highly recommended John when we decided to purchase a second home here in Milwaukee. His knowledge of the market and details to look for when making a home purchase was extremely helpful. We purchased a wonderful condo over looking the lake and couldn’t be happier. Now we are looking at investment properties and it continues to be a joy to work with John." - Annette & Mel B.

"John was amazing to work with when finding a home for my mom. He is very knowledgeable, Professional. He made the buying process a breeze. We can’t say enough about John he truly is the best. We will be using him again!" - Megan B. & Paula L.


"I’m an investor that was fortunate enough to get connected with John 6 years ago. He has been instrumental in helping me build my portfolio. Once again, John helped me close the deal on a investment property. I highly recommend John for all your real estate needs in Southeastern Wisconsin." - Dan G.

"John worked tirelessly to land us in our dream home - and got it done! After tens of showings, he kept a positive attitude while reassuring us it would work out. And thanks to his hard work - eventually finding a house and schmoozing the sellers on our behalf. Without John, we would either have given up our search or settled for less. Anyone would be lucky to have him!" - Melanie C. & Michael B.

"If you want to have an experienced professional in your corner to help you buy, sell or rent, John is your guy. He made our first apartment search and first home purchase experience wonderful in an extremely competitive market and continued to constantly bring positivity and a wealth of knowledge to make our experience top notch. John has all of the highest accolades and it was clear he deserves every single one. I would highly recommend working with John for any real estate needs." - Zach & Kaity J.

"John was amazing to work with. Very punctual and really took his time to take me around. He also helped us stay on top of deadlines for closing on our new house. I would highly recommend him as a realtor." - Heather S.

"My wife and I moved from Memphis, TN to the Milwaukee area this spring. With the housing market on absolute fire and multiple offers being made on all the houses we looked at John was an absolute bulldog in getting things done. This is the 3rd house we have bought, so far John has been the best realtor we have worked with. I can’t recommend him enough if you want a quality realtor with your best interests at heart." - Ryan S.

"We absolutely loved working with John and his team. As first-time home buyers, we wanted someone we could trust to help us through this process. John was that person! He was always available when we wanted to look at a house or when we had questions. When putting together offers he knew how to make us stand out. In this crazy market, he was a trusted friend to get us the first home of our dreams! I highly recommend John Molitor and his team!!!" - Tristan & Bradley P.

"John helped us look for houses and land for over a year in a very competitive, difficult market. He never hesitated to show us anything we were interested in, sometimes even same day, and is very knowledgeable, patient, and looks out for his clients. His support staff is also awesome! Once we found what we were looking for he made the offer to closing process very easy. Highly recommend!" - Kristyn & Jeff S.

"John has been a pleasure to work with. He helped us find our home in Cedarburg almost two years ago. Recently he helped us find the perfect spot in Door County. John is always responsive and works hard for you/us. We've closed on two properties with John and will continue to leverage him in the future when we need an agent that knows the market and is an absolute pleasure to work with." - Andy L. & Jessica C.

"If you are looking for a honest, hard working, and dedicated agent, then John Molitor is your guy. John helped me find the perfect investment property and made it fun to work with him. His knowledge and professionalism over the years definitely shows throughout your time working with him. I wouldn't want any other agent by my side during my house hunting. Thanks John!" - Collin L.

"We worked with John to buy our first home and we couldn't have asked for a better experience. Right from our initial meeting, he helped remove the stress of the process and instead made it fun and exciting. He was very accommodating and responsive, and worked tirelessly helping us make decisions and put offer letters together. He greeted us at every home tour with a big smile and excitement. He also was very helpful throughout the tours, pointing things out that first time home buyers wouldn't be thinking about. His knowledge of the market is excellent so we trusted his judgement in helping us decide what would be a good fit for us. We highly recommend working with John!" - Ali Y. & Joe H.

"John was amazing realtor for us. He was very approachable by txt/Call/email. We had a little complication regarding flood zoning for the property and he was on top of that from the get go and took all headache away from me. He contacted land surveyor and was guiding me through all the steps. If you are in market, look no further. John is awesome at what he does." - Mohit A. & Manana K.

"It was such a pleasure working with John when looking for a home in the Milwaukee area! He listened closely to what I was looking for and quickly honed in on several different possibilities. When I found "the one," he was there every step of the way. His professionalism was equaled only by his personable demeanor." - Pam W.

"John was so great to work with. He was persistent and stayed with us on a year long journey to find the right home. This was our first time buying a house, John was a great sounding board for all of our first time questions. Always stayed positive and assured us that we would find the right fit. John is very knowledgeable about the Milwaukee area and was able to provide tons of guidance on potential projects that would come with the purchase of each house we looked at. Highly recommend." - Mitch B. & Jessica N.

"John did a great job helping us find our family home. We were relocating from the west coast with a tight timeline, so it was a tough logistical challenge that John was able to navigate with ease." - Matt & Sam B.

"We have worked with John twice in two years and cannot sing his praises enough!! From the very early stages of both purchasing and renting through the end of the process, John is extremely helpful, thorough, and professional. When we began seriously searching for our first house, we knew right away that we wanted to work with John again (we had worked with him 2 years prior when renting our apartment). John works with your best interest in mind and fights to get the best deal for you as a buyer. He goes above and beyond during home tours to assist in pointing out and addressing technical details and areas of concern. He is easily available... MORE." - Lauren K. &

Ryan G.

"I let John know what I was looking for and he went to it. Came back with about a dozen places to look at. He sat down with me and went over the pros and cons of the two places I liked the most. I’ve now been in my house for six months and am the happiest I’ve been in a place. I love owning a home, especially one I’m in love with. Thanks John!" - Brett C.

"My experience with John has been positive and professional, always there for me. He was available and flexible. He went beyond the call of duty to be helpful, patient and honest. He has dignity and integrity and I trust his character and professional knowledge. I recommend John highly." - Annette R.

"John was an excellent guide for us through the home-buying process. He was extremely responsive at all times and very cheerful and positive as we looked at home after home until we found the right match. He provided good negotiating advice, helped us assess homes, leveraged his network of specialists, and just generally provided strong support to us. As a result eventually found just what we were looking for!" - Malek A. & Elisa C.

"Amazing experience — John is the best! He guided us through several homes, trained us to look for the details that enhanced or detracted value. He helped structure our purchase and got us through a rough financing process with grace and ease. Highly recommended!" - Josh S. & Janet S.

"John worked exceptionally well with my partner and I as out of town buyers. His knowledge of the city, its neighborhoods, and the market trends was evident with our first conversation. What we didn't know, was that we would also receive a realtor with a keen eye for detail, and many personal connections with trades people able to give immediate estimates for repairs and upgrades. John helped us find our forever home on the upper East side!" - Cara M. & Ariel N.

"We had a short time frame, and were very appreciative that John was able to show us the houses we wanted to see, and had a contract on a house day 2 of house hunting! Since we were relocating from Florida, John was very helpful and even went to a house for us and gave us a live virtual tour! He was great to work with and highly recommend!" - Julie J.

"John eased our process of purchasing a rental property. Once we found the perfect place, John was there to ensure the inspection went well, and was on hand for some additional tricky negotiations with the seller. Once we secured the home, John was ready to have the house listed to rent. He scoured the country for the right tenants for us. It was wonderful to work with John and we plan to continue working with him for our future real estate needs. I highly recommend his services in buying or renting!​" - Ellen P.

"John is helpful and professional person , and help me to buy a house in Whitefish Bay, I appreciate his great service. He provided fast response , and he is very familiar with Whitefish Bay area. If anyone would like to buy a house in Whitefish Bay, He will be a best choice." - I-Hsui L.

"I am fairly certain we rank as the highest maintenance clients John has had. He stayed in touch with us over the course of a couple years and was incredibly patient every step of the way; doing it all with a smile and never showing a hint of wanting to throw in the towel. We visited countless homes and ultimately found our home through old school marketing! We also sold our prior home through John and everything went very smoothly. John gave solid recommendations along the way - he knows the real estate market and Milwaukee very well! We highly recommend John to anyone considering a move!"​ - Jennifer N.

"We utilized John's services for both selling our home and buying our new home. We couldn't be more pleased with John's assistance during the whole process. From showing us a million homes all over Wisconsin to assisting us in negotiating with our buyer - he was there every step of the way. Whether  you are buying, selling, or renting, the best decision you can make in any future real estate endeavors would be to hire John Molitor. We would recommend him to anyone looking to get into the real estate game, and I would challenge anyone to find a better realtor, because I truly feel like one doesn't exist." - Rebecca & John N.

"I would 100% work with John if I were ever to buy another house. From negotiating our price down 65k+, to working with a not so nice seller, he help us purchase the house of our dreams and made sure we were comfortable throughout the whole process. He showed us house after house until we found the  one we agreed on, and then stayed in contact with us every day until closing. I have been recommending John to all of my friends and family and would guarantee you will not be disappointed if you decide to go with him!" - Chelsea & Mitch M.

"John is a very charismatic guy and a delight to work with. Made every step of the whole process very easy. If we ever decide to sell or buy another home he's the first one I'm going to call." - Eric R.

"John was very helpful and professional. I really appreciate all the help and support he offered us. His local knowledge came in handy and he was very accommodating toward our needs." - Roger P.


"John was extremely helpful throughout the entire process. He was in constant communication and even stopped by the house after a big rain storm the day before closing to make sure everything was good, without even asking. He is an expert at what he does and as a first time home buyer, he made it a  great experience for us. I would highly recommend John to anyone searching for a new home." - John D. and Lucy R.


"John is amazing! He showed us our new home many times and spent hours communicating with us. We were looking at our house from December and didn't close until mid may. We looked at the house at least 5 times. John is easy to get in touch with and always replies quickly." - Natalie and Ray H.


"First a little backstory, I’ve known John for years. We’ve played on the same softball team countless times over the years. So I knew what he did for a living. I remember when he was named 2016 Best Realtor in MKE, and thinking well we do know a lot of people could this really be true?? We started working together not long after that and to say in underestimated John would be well a gross understatement. A lot of things get said between friends but the professionalism and sheer knowledge of homes, markets, neighborhoods, and the buying and selling process amazes me even as I sit in the house John worked so endlessly to help me purchase. As a first time home buyer... MORE." - Walter N.


"John felt like family. He was always reassuring and got back to me when he said he would. Overall, I enjoyed working with John and wouldn't have had it any other way." - Wendell H. 


"John helped my wife and I find our first home, in what we learned is a very competitive market. He always made time for us, and he genuinely cares about making sure every question is answered during what is at times an overwhelming process. We couldn't be happier to have worked with someone like John, and I would recommend him to anyone looking to sell or buy a home." - Matt and Julia C.

"John was a pleasure to work with! He helped us every step of the way and answered any questions we had. In this highly competitive market, he showed us a home and wrote an aggressive offer in a matter of a couple which we the sellers accepted! I would recommend John to anyone!" - Marie F. 


"From my initial phone call to John, he was terrific. Every question I had, John, either had or found out the answers. I was consistently updated on the entire process of buying my first home and he couldn't have made the process any easier for me. I would recommend, John, to anyone looking to buy or sell a home." - Ryan G.


"Phenomenal! I can't say enough about how helpful John was throughout my first home buying experience. I'd have never expected it to go so smoothly. Unbelievably fast and willing to help with anything I needed along the way with super fast responses. Highly recommended!!" - T.J. W. and Robin J.


"John went above and beyond to help us find our first home! As first-time home buyers, we were pretty clueless as to the process and how everything worked as it can be pretty overwhelming. Luckily John was there for us every single step of the way. He was able to answer all of our questions and guide us through this exciting journey! He is extremely knowledgeable and truly had our best interest in mind. I will be recommending him to all of my friends and family for their real estate needs! Thank you so much John! We are forever grateful!" - Patty and Kevin D.


"We just closed on an amazing house in Milwaukee, thanks to John Molitor! John worked tirelessly to accommodate our limited schedules as we visited from New York a couple times to do whirlwind tours of homes in several neighborhoods that we knew we were interested in. He set up multiple showings, sometimes with very little notice. He is very responsive and very knowledgeable about markets and homes all over the Milwaukee area. We would highly... Let me repeat that... HIGHLY recommend John to our family, friends, and anyone in need of a real estate agent and we won't hesitate to call John for our real estate needs in the future." - Angela V. and Joe P.


"We were referred to John through a mutual friend/co-worker and we couldn't be happier! We toured many homes in Washington County but couldn't find what we thought was the perfect place for the next chapter in our lives. The market was CRAZY but we managed to find a condo that fits many of our needs and wants. John was very patient with us and very accommodating as our schedules didn't always line up but we made it and now we are getting ready to move this weekend after lots of painting!... MORE." - Alicia E. and Jay S.


"We finally did it- we bought our first home! The Milwaukee/Waukesha market is so hot right now, we did not think we would find anything and I go and fall in love with the first house John showed us. We toured several more homes but nothing compared. John and his whole team did an amazing job negotiating to get us the best deal and we closed the first week in June. John called right before my birthday to let us know our offer was accepted- best birthday ever! We are thrilled! John you are a serious Rockstar... MORE." - Erin and George B.


"We had a great experience working with John. We were on a tight time frame from moving from Cleveland, OH back to Milwaukee, WI. John had world class communication, was able to squeeze us in with very little notice and helped us find the house of our dreams with about a month. We appreciate your professionalism and friendliness and will recommend you to all our friends and family!" - Amanda O. and Don C. 


"John you did a great job with helping me and my girlfriend find a house. You worked late into the night with showing us houses and gathering paper work. It was never a dull moment and you made the stress of buying a house go away. Thank you for all of the help and thank you for your hard work." - John P. 


"We would work with John anytime. He is always there to help thru the whole process. He keeps you informed and is available for every question along the way. He makes sure everything is a good fit for you. You will never regret having him as your partner in the process." - Sue and Gary D. 


"John Molitor, thank you for helping us find a beautiful home for our family. You worked so hard to make sure we were completely satisfied and comfortable with our purchase. You were more than the realtor. You have a solution to fix all problems, have connections to fill in any gaps needed from contractors to cleaning professionals, you had a guy for everything. You were my go to for any concerns from the loan to insurance queries. You were so quick to make appointments for us and literally took us to see homes within an hours notice. You kept note of all of my questions and concerns for every home and asked about them for me even when I had forgotten. Your attention to detail is phenomenal. We really felt like we had someone looking out for our best interest while working with you... MORE." - Nazia and Shahid S.


"John was an integral part of the home buying process for us. What could have been a very stressful time was made much easier with a knowledgeable realtor who made the experience manageable and enjoyable. John really understood the market of our target area and provided us with insight on what to look for in a home. John also gave us great recommendations and advice prior to making our big decision. We had a great experience and would recommend John to anyone looking to buy or sell their home." - Ellen and Arkadiy P. 


"Thanks for being patient with all of the counter offers! How many counters did we do? 7-8? Your attention to detail and super fast response times to everything helped this process tremendously." - Bryan M.


"We met John during the sale of our home and immediately found his passion and energy to be inspiring; exactly what we needed for the purchase or our new home.  From day one, John was focused on providing the best service possible and connecting us with the perfect home.  John’s desire for perfection coupled with a team of equally driven individuals made us feel as if we were his only client.  We wouldn’t just recommend John Molitor; we would tell you that you need John Molitor." - Tony and Kelly C.


"To say that John Molitor is the very best at what he does as a real estate agent is a tremendous understatement. I was working with another agent and as my situation proved much more complex and ever-changing was referred to John to see if he was up for the challenge. Right from the beginning John from the first, sincere, smile, incomparable energy, intelligence, constant untiring enthusiasm and resourcefulness, John went WELL above and beyond...he wasn't just up for the challenges, he seemed to WELCOME them with confidence that consistently resulted in ACTION, not just words like too many professionals do...MORE." - Linda C.


"We have never worked with a more attentive realtor than John Molitor. From the first property view to the investment property we finally ended up purchasing (and there were quite a few in between), John always made immediate arrangements for us to view properties that interested us, not to mention getting us additional information within hours of our requests. John was always upfront with his thoughts on a property, good or bad; he never pushed us to buy in order to "get the sale." With his infectious smile and limitless energy, he made the process fun and well worth the journey. We will not hesitate to refer John to friends and family, and look forward to working with him again." - Terri and John K.


"The home buying experience was a long journey, and one that John successfully led.  With a small target area, specific tastes, and modest budget, John sought out to find the perfect home and did a fantastic job!  He moves quickly, follows-up well, stays attentive and always responsive.  He guided the process very well, and kept a very patient approach throughout. His expertise of the communities he works, market trends, sales data and the process all are very apparent.  Being a first time home buyer I relied on John for much of this information and he always over delivered. I would highly recommend John to anyone in the market; his hard work and dedication are sure to please!" - Joseph B.


"Dwight and I both would like to thank you for all you have done to help us find our home. It has been a pleasure. You didn't give up searching for us for a home until we found the right one. You were with us every step of the way and made everything so much easier. I don't think anyone could have gotten the job done with ease the way you did. You made our first home buying experience a great one and we will recommend you to anyone searching for a house either to buy or rent! We've found our realtor and thank you again for everything."  - Melinda W. and Dwight B.


"John, I wanted to pass on a huge thank you for all your hard work over the past 18 months. You are a true professional and we are so glad to have worked with you. We will recommend you to anyone who needs the services you provide. Thank you again and stay in touch!" - Camilla and Stephan N.

"John is an absolute pro at what he does. He was very quick to respond to my many texts, emails and phone calls, which was very reassuring to a first time home buyer. His knowledgeable answers to my numerous questions was extremely helpful. I highly recommend him." - John F.


bottom of page